Saturday, October 28, 2006


Benn the Younger Might Succeed where his Dad Failed

We learn today that Hilary Benn, Secretary of State for International Development, has openly entered the race for Labour's Deputy Leadership election, whenever that event might take place. Along with Peter Hain, he is the second Cabinet member to announce his candidature, though Jack Straw and Alan Johnson have both indicated their probably similar intents. Harriet Harman, the constitutional affairs minister, and John Cruddas, MP for Dagenham are the other two declared runners.

Picking the winner from this far out is impossible but, as they stroll around the paddock, the runners can be weighed up. Straw has gained a high recent profile from raising the veil issue- though whether this will count for or against him in the end is a moot point; I'd say it was fractionally negative at the moment. Harman is the only woman so far in the frame and this will help her, but she lacks name recognition and has never really recovered from her sacking in 1998, accompanied by her junior minister, Frank Field. Johnson is a real prospect for the job and, indeed, may well run for the leadership itself next Easter or whenever the contest is held to replace Blair. But he suffered some reversals as the 'top outsider' at the Manchester conference and needs to raise his profile.

John Cruddas, on the other hand, has arguably become the 'top outsider' for the deputy's job; the man whom, according to Paul Linford the unions and party members want to counter Establishment figures like Straw and Hain. He is also known, according to Paul, somewhat mystifyingly as 'The Blogger's Candidate'. There are several furlongs to run yet but he seems well placed.

So what,then, of Benn junior? I would say also well placed, having in his favour, the following advantages:

a) He is perceived as a competent minister- sad to say, a somewhat rare qualification in Blair governments. Moreover his department is seen as 'morally sound'- doing good socialistic things for needy people. Labour members like that.

b) He has a wide cross party appeal, and, according to an aide, 'will be able to rebuild the coalition that was so critical in 1997'.

c) Evidence of b) above is provided by the support of Dennis Skinner for the fresh faced Been junior; the 'Beast of Bolsover' carries clout as probably the best known representative of the Old Labour tendency in the party.

d) Ian McCartney, the diminutive trade minister and former party chairman - himself a formidable organizer and Labour fixer- is standing by to offer support.

e) Finally, Tony Benn was arguably a disruptive influence in the early eighties who helped prolong Labour's years in the wilderness. But this is not how all members see it and Benn's longevity as an unreconstructed socialist rebel has made him, paradoxically, into a species of National Treasure. His determined campaigns and scrupulous politeness won him respect from all over the House, even including the Conservative benches('we love his manners' Julian Critchley once told me). The now revered position of Hilary's once troublesome father will certainly be an assist in his bid to succeed where Dad failed, by just one per cent, way back in 1981.

You know about such things Skip. Is the election a simple FPTP or does someone have to get a clear majority and, if so, from which of the three groups of electors?

PS If I had to vote today I'd go for H Benn MP...
Ian McCartney?! He not only looks like Wee Jimmy Cranky...he even looks like him! Formidable?! Really?
The election is an exhaustive ballot, i.e. preferential voting with the winner needing 50% plus one. That is of the total aggregated vote across the three electoral college sections - you don't need to achieve majority or even plurality in all or any one of them, just overall.

We'll be sticking with Cruddas, but it's certainly shaping up to be an interesting and exciting race whoever you're cheering for.
Benn is totally establishment, make no mistake and as for his father, some of us think he was the worst cabinet minister this country ahs ever known. Jon Cruddas is the only choice for any party member who wishes to rebuild our party. Have the other MPs in the contest seen their CLP membership rise consistently over 18 solid months? THAT is what Cruddas needs to do and will do for our party as Deputy Leader.
If Dennis is backing him, that is interesting.... 'cos he loathes the old man.
"He not only looks like Wee Jimmy Cranky...he even looks like him!"

Micky's been on the pop again.
as for his father, some of us think he was the worst cabinet minister this country ahs ever known

Saw Benn speak at the Oxford Union last week; he was fabulous. Judgements about his cabinet competency aside (I'd beg to differ with your analysis), the old man certainly deserves respect for his continued rhetorical flair. Admittedly some substance was lacking (he did not engage with the N Korea/Iran poser, instead focusing on the "rouge state" of America) and he does re-use a few quips/anecdotes (they're so good that we can forgive him this transgression), but as far as populist elocution is concerned Benn is a genius. He certainly had me clapping loudly, along with the rest of the chamber.
And by the way, Benn snr said he was "very proud" of his son, and thought him an exceptional minister in an age of incompetence.

(But would he have said anything else?!)
SPL: Your blog has gone a bit quiet recently. Surely they don't work you that hard at Oxford? Glad to see you haven't deserted the blogosphere altogether.
I'm with Politaholic on this one. Surely with all that time to consume industrial quantities of alcohol and drugs, you can find enough to keep on blogging....?
I think where Cruddas wins in the deputy election is in his interesting ideas for reforming the job and rebuilding the party.

I'd like to see Benn run for leader that should make things interesting.
Tony Benn - that silver-spooned lefty. Responsible for frightening people of the SE into voting tory in the 1980s. He was still alright though in his Belgravia town house (or wherever he lived); when industry was closed and unemployment broke new records.
Politaholic and Skipper

I'm leaving (industrial quantities of) drugs in the cupboard on Friday to go to watch Adam Boulton (of all detestable people) speak on the "impact of the blogosphere".* After that, if he has anything worthwhile to say - judging by his performance in a debate the other week, chances are slim - I may blog on his conclusions...accepting that, in order to have the slightest of impacts, or even (probably) the illusion of such, one probably needs to write something in the first place.

* - Actually, the said drugs, supplied by none other than Skipper, might help me to cut through the Boulton dross more clearly / stay awake.

It's too harsh to call Benn a "silver-spooned" lefty. His campaign against forced inheritance of the peerage was sincere. It's provincial - and, indeed, wrong - of impoverished lefties to think they enjoy a monopoly on socialism.
IHd7YI The best blog you have!
OvzLWK Good job!
Good job!
Wonderful blog.
Good job!
Nice Article.
Wonderful blog.
Please write anything else!
Wonderful blog.
K8e1Lq write more, thanks.
Wonderful blog.
Wonderful blog.
Nice Article.
Please write anything else!
Good job!
Hello all!
Good job!
actually, that's brilliant. Thank you. I'm going to pass that on to a couple of people.
Nice Article.
Thanks to author.
Please write anything else!
Please write anything else!
What is a free gift ? Aren't all gifts free?
If ignorance is bliss, you must be orgasmic.
Oops. My brain just hit a bad sector.
I'm not a complete idiot, some parts are missing!
Beam me aboard, Scotty..... Sure. Will a 2x10 do?
Lottery: A tax on people who are bad at math.
Good job!
Give me ambiguity or give me something else.
Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?